Skip to main content

Full text of "Is Ireland a Nation?"

See other formats

Irish Question, No- 15] 


" She is a nation."— Mr. Paknell, House of Commons, 
May 13, 1886. 

<( We wish to see Ireland what God intended she should be — 
a powerful nation."— Mr. T. M. Healy, at Boston, Dec. 24, 


"Has England any more right to keep a neighbouring 
people in Slavery for her profit or pleasure than the planter 
of Jamaica or the slave-owner of Alabama had that right ? '' — Sir 
C. Gavan Duffy, Contemporary Beview, May, 1886. 

This is the demand of the Irish Nationalists — that Ireland shall 
have a Separate Parliament, because the Irish (or rather 
the majority of Irish Catholics) are a Separate nation from 
the inhabitants of Great Britain, are an oppressed and mis- 
governed nationality, who cannot get justice from the Imperial 

This demand (never before admitted by a responsible 
English statesman) is now suddenly conceded by Mr. Glad- 
stone's Government. Liberal policy for the last 20 years has 
been to do justice to Ireland. Mr. Gladstone now asks us to 
take " a new departure v and set aside Liberal laws, how- 
ever just, because, coming to Ireland "in a foreign garb," 
they fail to conciliate the Irish National sentiment. His Chief 
Secretary, Mr. John Morley, compares Ireland under the rule of 
the Imperial Parliament to Greece or Bulgaria under the Turks, 
or Italy under the Austrians. 

When our kinsfolk, the Americans of the Northern States, 
were asked, twenty -five years ago, to grant independence to the 
Southern Confederation as a separate nation, they replied that 

they could not " subordinate geographical considera- 
tions to national sentiment." 

We Englishmen are now asked to subordinate not only 

geographical, but Imperial, economical, political and 

( 2 ) 

moral considerations to the national sentiment of the Irish 
Catholic majority. 

Geographical : because Ireland is only sixty miles distant 
from England, and only twenty miles from Scotland. . ' 

Imperial : because the union of the vast British Empire will 
be seriously weakened by any loosening of the bonds of the 
United Kingdom. 

Economical * because the trade and prosperity of England 
and Ireland will be undoubtedly injured by their separation. 

Political: because the Parliament of the United Kingdom 
will be broken up and reduced to a Parliament of Great Britain 

And Moral, because England will be unable to fulfil her 
obligations to the loyal and law-abiding inhabitants of Ireland. 
who demand that they shall not be deserted. 

Englishmen, will you subordinate all these con 
siderations to Irish national sentiment? or will you 

not rather, like your American brethren, offer a determined 
and Successful resistance to this attempt to create within 

the United Kingdom two nations, two Parliaments, and 
two laws? 

Kemember that if we once recognise the Irish Catholics as a 
Separate nation, we cannot justly or logically refuse theiu 

that complete independence which is the right of every 

separate nation! Did not Mr. Parnell himself say at Cork, 

January 21, 1885 :— " No man has the right to fix the 
boundary to the march of a nation." 

Kemember the words of Lord Spencer, when Lord Lieutenant 
of Ireland under Mr. Gladstone's last Government : — 

" We hold that the continued union of Ireland with this 
country is of vital importance to us. We feel like the 

Americans when the integrity of their country was 
threatened, and, if necessaiy, we must shed blood 
to maintain the strength and salvation of this 

country.— Bristol, Nov. 14, 1881. 

Published by the Liberal Committee for the Maintenance of the 

Legislative Union between Great Britain and Ireland, 

35, Spring Gardens, S.W.